The short version
- Vinyl plank is the safest choice anywhere water is likely, including basements.
- Solid hardwood can be refinished for decades, but it doesn’t belong below grade.
- Whatever you choose, the subfloor underneath decides how well it lasts.
The four main options
| Floor | Water | Wear | Refinish? | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Luxury vinyl plank | Handles it well | Tough, resists scratches | No | Basements, kitchens, bathrooms, busy households |
| Laminate | Better than it used to be, still vulnerable at the seams | Hard-wearing surface | No | Bedrooms, living rooms, hallways |
| Engineered hardwood | Dislikes standing water | Real wood surface that can dent | Sometimes, depending on the wear layer | Main floors, and over concrete where the maker allows it |
| Solid hardwood | Dislikes water and humidity swings | Dents and scratches, but repairable | Yes, several times | Main and upper floors |
Luxury vinyl plank
Vinyl plank has become the default for good reason. It shrugs off spills, wet boots and pets, it’s comfortable underfoot, and the better products look convincingly like wood. It’s the floor we recommend most for basements, because it tolerates the moisture a concrete slab gives off.
What it can’t do is be refinished. When the surface is worn, the floor is replaced.
Laminate
Laminate has a very hard surface that stands up well to scratches. Its weak point is water at the seams, which can swell the core. Newer water-resistant lines are much better than the old ones, but it’s still not the floor for a bathroom or a basement that has ever been damp.
Engineered hardwood
Engineered hardwood is a layer of real wood over a stable core. It moves less with humidity than solid wood, which is why some products can go over concrete. It looks and feels like hardwood because the surface is hardwood. How many times it can be refinished depends on how thick that top layer is.
Solid hardwood
Solid hardwood is the long game. It can be sanded and refinished several times across decades, and it suits the character of an older home. It also expands and contracts with humidity and dislikes water, so it stays out of bathrooms and basements.
And tile
For bathrooms, entries and many kitchens, tile is still the most durable and waterproof choice. It’s harder underfoot and colder, unless floor heat is added during the renovation.
Room by room
- Basement: vinyl plank or tile.
- Bathroom: tile or vinyl plank.
- Kitchen: tile, vinyl plank or engineered hardwood, depending on how hard the room is used.
- Entry and mudroom: tile or vinyl plank.
- Living room and bedrooms: any of them. Choose for look and feel.
The subfloor decides how long it lasts
Most flooring failures start underneath: a soft spot, a loose sheet, a dip or dampness. Squeaks, gaps and cracked tile usually trace back to a subfloor that wasn’t checked. Before any new floor goes down, the subfloor should be inspected, fastened, levelled and dry. It adds a little time, and it’s what separates a floor that lasts from one that looks tired in two years.
See how we handle flooring installation, including the preparation.
Planning a project like this?
We’ll come out, look at the space and give you a clear written price. The estimate is free. Read more about our flooring installation.